Two very different books about two very different games
The Shantae Official Strategy Guide and We Love Mystery Dungeon (Hardcover) both cover classic game series, but they serve opposite purposes. One is a play-along walkthrough for a single title; the other is a broad history and analysis of an entire genre. Your choice depends on whether you want help beating a game or context for understanding one.
Neither book is a novel, and neither is a coffee-table art book. The Shantae guide is a reference you keep open while playing; the Mystery Dungeon book is a read-through that explains how roguelikes evolved. Below, the supplied details for each are laid out so you can match the book to your actual use case.
What the Shantae Official Strategy Guide actually contains
- Shantae Official Strategy Guide: The first-ever official strategy guide for the original Shantae, produced in collaboration with Matt and Erin Bozon. This is a primary-source guide for one specific game, not a series overview. If you want official coverage of the original Shantae, this is the book.

Shantae Official Strategy Guide - Shantae Official Strategy Guide: Features a complete walkthrough, including boss strategies, item and dance locations, combat tactics, and a rundown of where to find every Firefly. These are practical, play-along contents. The value comes from using it while you play, not from reading it cover to cover.
- Shantae Official Strategy Guide: First in a series of six guides. If you prefer to collect a matched set, this is the opening volume. That may matter more to completists than to someone who only wants help with the first game.
What We Love Mystery Dungeon covers
- We Love Mystery Dungeon (Hardcover): An unofficial and completely unauthorized look at the Mystery Dungeon games, penned by John Harris, whose Game Developer column @Play helped spread the word of the roguelike genre. This is a critical history and analysis, not an official walkthrough. It suits readers who want context and commentary rather than step-by-step help.

We Love Mystery Dungeon (Hardcover) - We Love Mystery Dungeon (Hardcover): Explores the Mystery Dungeon games (and the Shiren the Wanderer series in particular) on both a macro and micro level—comparing releases, explaining mechanics, and offering translation keys for unlocalized titles. The scope is a whole franchise and its design, including import-friendly reference material. That is a different job from a single-game guide.
- We Love Mystery Dungeon (Hardcover): Accompanied by original hand-painted illustrations that complement the Shiren games' emphasis on traditional calligraphy and watercolors. Presentation is part of the appeal here. If you want a book to browse and display, this matters more than it would in a walkthrough.
How they compare on the things buyers actually weigh
The two books differ on nearly every axis that matters for a purchase decision. Use this table to see where each one fits.
- Primary purpose: Shantae guide: complete walkthrough for one game. Mystery Dungeon book: history and analysis of a genre and series.
- Official status: Shantae guide: official, produced with the original creators. Mystery Dungeon book: unofficial and unauthorized.
- Format: Shantae guide: format not confirmed in the supplied details. Mystery Dungeon book: hardcover.
- Scope: Shantae guide: the original Shantae. Mystery Dungeon book: multiple Mystery Dungeon games, with emphasis on Shiren the Wanderer.
- Best use: Shantae guide: beside you while playing. Mystery Dungeon book: reading for context, comparison, and reference.
- Series commitment: Shantae guide: first of six planned guides. Mystery Dungeon book: stands alone.
Which book fits your shelf
If you are actively playing the original Shantae and want official help finding every Firefly, dance, and item, the Shantae Official Strategy Guide is the practical choice. Its contents are built around play, and the collaboration with Matt and Erin Bozon gives it a primary-source quality that unofficial guides cannot match.
If you are more interested in how roguelikes evolved, how Mystery Dungeon adapted series like Dragon Quest, Pokémon, and Final Fantasy, or you want a readable history with hand-painted illustrations, We Love Mystery Dungeon is the better fit. It is a book to read and think about, not a walkthrough to follow.
One honest limitation: the supplied details do not confirm the Shantae guide's format (hardcover or softcover) or page count. If physical format is a dealbreaker, treat that as an open question rather than assuming. The Mystery Dungeon book is confirmed as hardcover.
A quick way to decide
- You want to beat the original Shantae with official help: Choose the Shantae Official Strategy Guide.
- You want to understand Mystery Dungeon and roguelike history: Choose We Love Mystery Dungeon.
- You are starting a guide collection: The Shantae guide is the first in a six-part series, so it may appeal if you like matched sets.
- You want a hardcover for the shelf: We Love Mystery Dungeon is confirmed hardcover; the Shantae guide's binding is not confirmed in the supplied information.



